Tuesday, May 11, 2021

Athletics Threaten to Leave Oakland if City Does Not Approve Howard Terminal Plan

I was planning on writing a post today about the first minor league games played last week in 20 months, but breaking news just now is that MLB is "suggesting" (pressuring) the A's to explore relocating their team if Oakland does not approve their latest ballpark proposal.  I say "breaking news," but any ballpark or baseball enthusiast knows the saga of the Athletics by now and their never-ending quest to get out of the Coliseum.  Their original Cisco Field plans in nearby Fremont date all the way back to 2006, which pre-dates even The Tour.  The latest site - Howard Terminal - has had some preliminary environmental studies commissioned and reviewed and has been the most promising to date, but even that site is on its 3rd iteration in 4 years.  This just continues to drag on as the city refuses to vote or commit to funding any sort of infrastructure improvements, despite the fact that the A's are footing the entire stadium bill.

This certainly isn't the first team to blackmail their municipality into approving a new stadium, nor will it be the last, but this is definitely a unique situation compared to most.  Most teams that do this (including my hometown Brewers and NBA Bucks) are after some sort of stadium financial or tax incentive, but in the case of the A's, the heart of the issue is whether Oakland wants to take on the massive project of converting an active industrial seaport that is difficult to access into a live/work entertainment hub like so many other contemporary stadiums have.  I understand that there are going to be environmental and logistical challenges with this site, but given the relatively low amount of money involved with this compared to most stadium deals, and the fact that the city has already lost an NBA and NFL franchise in the last few years, it really seems like a no-brainer to approve this.  However, there are some advocates, the most vocal of which being the East Oakland Stadium Alliance, that want to see the A's just build in the parking lot next door to their current stadium (similar to what the Brewers and Mets did), which does make some sense given the site is already set up for transit and the team owns half of the land.  But the A's are getting to the point where the Coliseum is so bad and so beyond its functional life that they simply do not have the time to explore even one more site - simply put, it's Howard Terminal, or they move.

Today's announcement represents a last-ditch effort by A's to rectify this situation before their latest lease ends in 2024 and before MLB starts to take a more active hand in coercing the situation.  Rob Manfred has made it well known that he plans to expand the league to 32 teams but will not do so until the Oakland and Tampa stadium situations are resolved, so this has been sort of an irritating rash during his entire tenure as commissioner.  I know I speak for Erik when I say that we are rooting for this project to move forward...but also would not be sad if we got to go to maybe Portland or Las Vegas instead of Oakland.

STANDINGS AND UPCOMING SERIES AS OF 5/11/21:
Brewers 19-16, -2.0; 3 v. Cardinals, 3 v. Braves, 2 @ Royals, 3 @ Reds
Twins 12-20, -7.0; 3 @ White Sox, 3 v. Athletics, 3 v. White Sox, 2 @ Angels, 3 @ Indians

2021 GAMES ATTENDED:
Erik - 0
Peter - 0

No comments: